Electric EDGE
Web Edition of The Ragged Edge
January/February 1997
Electric Edge


By David Mitchell

Stories of overcoming and cure abound in our culture, from Olympians who "overcome" everything from asthma to the Keating Five scandal, to hourly CNN spots about amputees who climb mountains on prosthetic limbs and play basketball in wheelchairs.

The triumph-over-tragedy story is our most beloved plot line. But, as philosophers have shown, the story that is most repeated in a culture is also the one which reveals the most about those who produce and consume it.

What is so attractive about stories of overcoming deformities, disabilities, disfigurements and bodily dysfunctions? European and American societies have always tried to prove their "humane-ness" by enlisting disenfranshised and disabled communities as the tokens of their progressive commitments. When [Christopher] Reeve [in his speech to the 1996 Democratic National Convention] invoked people with disabilities as those in need of being "valued" as part of the "American family," his appeal was saying that disability automatically excludes one from holding a definitive social value; that disabled people could not affirm their own value without the approval of non- disabled citizens and institutions.

Reeve went on to connect our "nation's mission of hope" to the cure of people with disabilities in general (and the cure of spinal cord injury in particular). The national mission of curing disabilities led Reeve hyperbolically to compare the regeneration of nerve cells with "placing a man on the moon."

In making this curious parallel, Reeve voiced a powerful national sentiment. Though Reeve and the Democrats seemed to extoll the value of the lives of disabled people, their rhetoric established a perpetual future tense in which we see the "conquering" of disabilities as the foundation of a progressive national myth: Disability and people with disabilities are suspended in the future tense of national endeavor. They are a people who "we" need to be reminded to value from year and year (and convention to convention), but their "value" never quite arrives. If disability is central to our formulations and definitions of national progress (what population could replace them as the markers of our generous commitment to "all" people?), then that future time of cure must never arrive.

The key tension that exists in nearly all stories about disability is seen most clearly in the "cure narrative." It's a story of uneasy obliteration, for it always ends in the "loss" of the object upon which it depends: Either the disability is eradicated and surrenders its seductive interest, or it resists conforming to the narrative of its rehabilitation and the evidence of that refusal must itself be obliterated. This is what Paul Longmore means by the "cure or kill" paradigm: both get rid of disability.

The power of stories about disability, their perpetual lure for viewers and readers, goes beyond this, however. Their seduction is in that they promise a frontier that will never be exhausted. Unlike flights to the moon or the exploration of the West, disability is an inexhaustible resource. Its promise lies in the paradox that it can be perennially accessed without ever being fully dealt with -- its mystery cannot be pierced, because disabilities stand as the evidence that human variation is the rule and not the exception. Disability's unique "value" is its status as an inexhaustible resource ripe for metaphorization in the never-ending story of national progress.

David Mitchell co-directed the documentary video "VITAL SIGNS: Crip Culture Talks Back," grand prizewinner at the 18th annual World Congress of Rehabilitation Internation's film and video festival. He is currently writing a book about the history of disability in philosophy and literature entitled The Materiality of Metaphor: Disability in the Western Tradition.

David Mitchell is assistant professor of English at Northern Michigan University.

Write to The Ragged Edge

Back to cover page | Table of Contents
Copyright 1996 The Ragged Edge

This Website produced by Cliffwood Organic Works